TY - JOUR
T1 - Zoning and activity-based post occupancy evaluation of multipurpose auditorium in campus facility
AU - Dewi, Ova Candra
AU - Putra, Nandy
AU - Yatim, Ardiyansyah
AU - Mahlia, T. M.Indra
AU - Rahmasari, Kartika
AU - Hanjani, Tika
AU - Siregar, Rizki
AU - Rangin, Bagus
AU - Izzatur, Nadhira
N1 - Funding Information:
This research was funded by the Directorate of Research and Development, Universitas Indonesia, under International Indexed Publication Grants (PUTI 2022) (Grant No. NKB-705/UN2.RST/HKP.05.00/2022). Also, the authors would like to thank Kwarista Dharma Smitha as a student assistant for actively participating in this study.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 Elsevier B.V.
PY - 2023/9/15
Y1 - 2023/9/15
N2 - Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) is necessary to evaluate the building's performance in order to formulate future design development after its utilisation. This paper evaluates indoor thermal performance, sound pressure level, and illuminance in a multipurpose auditorium by combining zoning and activity-based POE. The evaluation was done in three activities: (A) student graduation, (B) theater performance, and (C) public lecture with different types of clothing preferences. Three different zones were used to define the precise location of the building improvement. Field measurements were taken for thermal performance, including Operative Temperature (Top), Humidity (Rh), Sound Pressure Level (dB), and Illuminance (lux). User perceptions were collected from 171 respondents (89 men and 82 women). The field measurement showed that average operative temperature varied across the activities with 26.15–25.68 °C, 25.47–24.95 °C, and 23.74–23.17 °C on activities A, B, and C, respectively. Activity A's (1 clo) room's operative temperature showed that 65% of data are outside the ASHRAE standard, indicating that the room condition is unsuitable for 1 clo. Activity A's TSV shows a slightly warm sensation (0.21 to 0.93) and is still in the comfort range. With the same clothing value (0.6 clo), Activity B's Top indicates a more suitable condition than Activity C's. The average TSV in Activity B indicates slightly cool (-0.54 to −0.90), with the lowest TSV found in Activity C (-1.09 to −1.41). Although TSV positively correlates with PMV, Thermal Preference (TP) revealed that the occupant expects cooler conditions in all activities. Sound pressure level and illuminance performed well according to all activities. This paper recommends chiller setting adjustment in the multipurpose auditorium based on activity characteristics. Combined POE based on zoning and activity can indicate which aspects of the auditorium need to be improved.
AB - Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) is necessary to evaluate the building's performance in order to formulate future design development after its utilisation. This paper evaluates indoor thermal performance, sound pressure level, and illuminance in a multipurpose auditorium by combining zoning and activity-based POE. The evaluation was done in three activities: (A) student graduation, (B) theater performance, and (C) public lecture with different types of clothing preferences. Three different zones were used to define the precise location of the building improvement. Field measurements were taken for thermal performance, including Operative Temperature (Top), Humidity (Rh), Sound Pressure Level (dB), and Illuminance (lux). User perceptions were collected from 171 respondents (89 men and 82 women). The field measurement showed that average operative temperature varied across the activities with 26.15–25.68 °C, 25.47–24.95 °C, and 23.74–23.17 °C on activities A, B, and C, respectively. Activity A's (1 clo) room's operative temperature showed that 65% of data are outside the ASHRAE standard, indicating that the room condition is unsuitable for 1 clo. Activity A's TSV shows a slightly warm sensation (0.21 to 0.93) and is still in the comfort range. With the same clothing value (0.6 clo), Activity B's Top indicates a more suitable condition than Activity C's. The average TSV in Activity B indicates slightly cool (-0.54 to −0.90), with the lowest TSV found in Activity C (-1.09 to −1.41). Although TSV positively correlates with PMV, Thermal Preference (TP) revealed that the occupant expects cooler conditions in all activities. Sound pressure level and illuminance performed well according to all activities. This paper recommends chiller setting adjustment in the multipurpose auditorium based on activity characteristics. Combined POE based on zoning and activity can indicate which aspects of the auditorium need to be improved.
KW - Auditorium
KW - Building Performance
KW - Campus Facility
KW - Post Occupancy Evaluation (POE)
KW - Thermal Comfort
KW - Zoning
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85163865828&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.enbuild.2023.113319
DO - 10.1016/j.enbuild.2023.113319
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85163865828
SN - 0378-7788
VL - 295
JO - Energy and Buildings
JF - Energy and Buildings
M1 - 113319
ER -